I know that in so many aspects of his ministry as Pope, Leo is doing extremely well, and is a blessing to the world at this time. In a strange way, I think he also benefits from the presence of Trump in his native United States. The sheer extreme nature of Trump’s words and action serve to provide an ideal forum for Leo, whose words and actions are in such contrast to Trump that they stand out and resonate all around the world, far beyond the Catholic believers. He is increasingly the main voice for sanity and decency in the world crying out for those values.
But I am uneasy about him in relation to Church reform. His responses to the media questions in the plane on his return from South America give cause, I believe, for some concern. It is reported that in response to nearly every question he was asked by various journalists he consistently returned to the theme of unity and his desire to work against polarisation both in the church and society at large. In theory that is an excellent position to adopt, and it is hard to argue with it at that level.
But when he came to some of the specifics of this policy, as he sees them working out, we come to the following, as reported:
Two days after visiting the Peruvian Amazon, Leo said that the proposal to ordain married men to the priesthood, which was a central topic of debate during a 2018 Vatican summit on the Amazon, is “a solution which in certain areas of the church can cause division.” And then he went on to say, in response to a question from Gerard O’Connell of America Magazine, “There is not universal acceptance of that concept,” and followed that by that by stating that among his priorities is:
“ first to promote unity and communion among us as members of the church.“
So to sum up, Leo’s position as regards the Church is as follows. He wants to promote unity and communion in the whole church, and avoid polarisation of any sort. In order to do that he will make no changes that are not universally accepted and may cause division.
This policy, while sounding good, is laden with problems, and indeed contradictions. There is already lots of polarisation in our church, in the sense that people’s views vary greatly in different parts of the world. Some want to go back to the pre-Vatican II church, and some want to move forward from where we are to further changes. These views can be deeply held, and all the dialogue in the world won’t bring them together. Also the Church’s position on women has caused enormous polarisation, in the sense that droves of women have left the Church, and young women want nothing to do with an institution where there is no equality. So if you decide you will not do anything to change this situation because some parts of the world will not agree with it, and it will cause division, then all you are doing is replacing one type of division with another.
The end result of this policy is that the power rests with the most traditional, conservative and unyielding groups in our church. And now that they know they have such power, and that they can block any change, they will certainly be unlikely to change their positions. And in the meantime, those of us, and our numbers are very large around the world, who want to see change and reform, will be more and more alienated.
As I see it, the future of the Church lies not in an enforced unity, but in diversity. Let each region of the Church move at its own pace, so if, for instance, the Belgians want to ordain married men, let the do it, and it doesn’t mean that everyone else has to do the same.
Is this wishful thinking?