James Alison restored to ministry; case similar to mine


Fr. James Alison

Pope Francis made a phone call to a leading gay theologian and priest who was suspended from active ministry in part over his LGBTQ-affirming work, and gave the theologian “the power of the keys,” a phrase indicating his restoration to active priesthood.

Francis placed the call two years ago to Fr. James Alison who only yesterday shared in The Tablet his account of the experience, which was first reported about anonymously in Frédéric Martel’s In the Closet of the Vatican published earlier this year.  In Alison’s account, he begins by explaining his suspension from ministry by the Vatican’s Congregation for Clergy in the 1990s:

“. . .I had been forcibly removed from clerical status, and was forbidden to teach, preach or preside. And that this was unappealable. Even for someone predisposed to imagine a Kafka-esque quality to Vatican bureaucracy it was shocking to be tangential to a process in which it is unnecessary to inform the one charged of the charges against him, in which no legal representation is permitted, and whose sentence does not require the signature of the sentence.”

Most bishops and church leaders would not support Alison, some being unwilling to even be seen meeting with him. Yet, a bishop with whom he was friendly eventually said he would request a private audience with Pope Francis and plead Alison’s case. The priest’s sharing continued:

“Eighteen months later, the bishop had his private audience, bearing with him a letter from me appealing what the Congregation had claimed was unappealable. My letter pointed out that the whole process smacked of the ‘self-referential curialism’ that Francis has so often criticised. And that I had been doing exactly what he had publicly encouraged us to do: to evangelise in an existential periphery, and ’cause a bit of a stir’. In the letter, I exposed my conscience to him: that I could not reconcile what he himself had said in public with the Latin document sent to me in his name, and was proposing to treat that document as null, and to carry on as before.

“I asked Francis, if at all possible, to make my situation regular, not as a personal favour to me, but as part of opening up wider ministerial possibilities in the Church for LGBT people to speak, preach, evangelise, in the first person, no longer bound by the dreaded ‘they’ of clerical dishonesty.”

Alison’s case was known by the pope by May 2017, a step which the theologian considered to be significant progress. But an even more significant step would occur:

“Then came the call: Sunday 2 July 2017 at about 3 p.m. Him: ‘Soy el Papa Francisco’; Me: ‘¿en serio?’; Him: ‘No, en broma hijo’ (‘This is Pope Francis’; ‘Are you serious?’; ‘No, just joking, son’). But it was he. The Argentinian accent, but more the fact that he knew the content of my letter, and was clearly referring to it as he spoke, clinched for me that this was no prank played by a cruel friend.

“And then this: ‘I want you to walk with deep interior freedom, following the Spirit of Jesus. And I give you the power of the keys. Do you understand? I give you the power of the keys.’ I said, ‘Yes’, though in retrospect, how, in my daze, I thought I had understood the gift is beyond me. The conversation went on, talking with humour, and even a certain piquancy, about friends and acquaintances in common. In the background a hint of lyric opera, which I strained to recognise. After urging me to discretion, not to cause problems for good bishops, he ended with ‘Pray for me. I’ll look up your dossier and get back to you.’ “

The call was an “extraordinary mercy,” Alison wrote, with implications for not only him, but others. The pope, it seemed, “did not regard as binding his own Congregation’s sentence” and “clearly treated [Alison] as a priest” with universal jurisdiction to hear Confessions. Alison explained further:

“That [Francis] was trusting me to be free to be responsibly the priest that I have spent all these years becoming; that for the first time in my life in the Church I had been treated as an adult by an adult, and, good Lord! It takes the Pope himself to act like that . . .Thirty years a priest, and it feels as though only now is my ordination kicking in. Having received, in addition, such freedom, how now should I exercise a ministry? With whom and for whom? In what good ways to be accountable, and to whom? Pope Francis has talked about this being a change of epoch rather than an epoch of change. What is going to be the shape of ministry in the Church that is being birthed? What is the form and style of teaching? These are, thank heaven, up in the air in ways I could never have imagined when as a frightened and classically-minded youth I lay prostrate before a bishop on a cold floor in 1988, full of intellectual certainty, hoping for some emotional security to match: and instead received from the Holy Spirit a 30-year blast into adulthood.”


I read this article with great interest, since it contained so much that is similar to my own experience.  I wouldn’t claim to have the theological knowledge and ability of James Alison, but in my own way, through my pastoral ministry and writing I think I can fairly claim that I too have “evangelised in an existential periphery, and ’caused a bit of a stir’”

Some have made representations on my behalf, but they have done so by appealing to the CDF for clemency, an approach that I did not approve of, because it was handing back to the CDF the power and control that Francis clearly is trying to take from them.

In Alison’s case his friendly bishop went directly to Francis, who overruled the CDF, and restored him to ministry.

Unfortunately it seems that I do not have any equivalent person, either in the Redemptorists or in the Irish hierarchy.

So be it.